We thank GOD for all the Services of all our former vicars.
| Vicars of the Past Quarter Century | ||
| (including Vicars of the Mar Thoma Congregation of Greater New York) | ||
| Mar Thoma Congregation of Greater New York | ||
| Rev. Oommen Koruthu | (Student Achen later elevated as | May 1975 Aug. 1975 |
| Bishop Zacharias Mar Theophilus) | ||
| Rev. K. S. Mathew | (Student Achen) | Sept. 1975 Sept. 1977 |
| Rev. Thomas P. George | (Student Achen) | Sept. 1977 Aug. 1979 |
| (Late) Rev. M. V. Benjamin | Sept. 1979 May 1981 | |
| St. Thomas Mar Thoma Church, New York | ||
| (Late) Rev. M. V. Benjamin | Co-Chairman Ad-hoc Committee Church in formation | Oct. 1980 - Jan. 1981 |
| Vicar | Jan. 1981 - May 1981 | |
| (Late) Rev. K. J. Philip | Co-Chairman Ad-hoc Committee Church in formation | Oct. 1980 - Jan. 1981 |
| Associate Vicar | Jan. 1981 - Aug. 1981 | |
| Rev. N. M. Cherian | Vicar of all Mar Thoma Congregations in New York | May 1981 - June 1983 |
| Rev. Dr. T. Jacob Thomas | (Student Achen) | |
| Assistant Vicar | July 1981 - May 1983 | |
| Vicar | June 1983 - Mar. 1985 | |
| Rev. Dr. G. Varghese | Mar. 1985 - April 1989 | |
| Rev. Johnson Varghese | June 1989 - May 1992 | |
| Rev. Dr. T. P. Abraham | June 1992 - May 1995 | |
| Rev. P. M. Thomas | May 1995 - April 1999 | |
| Rev. K. Y. Jacob | May 1999 - June 1999 | |
| Rev. Thomas P. Chandy | June 1999 - May 2002 | |
| Rev. Dr. K. A. Abraham | May 2002 - August 2004 | |
| Rev. Jojan Mathews John | May 2004 - April 2007 | |
| Rev. P. E. Mathew | May 2007 - April 2010 | |
| Rev. Joseph Johnny | May 2010 - April 2013 | |
| Rev. K. K. Samuel | May 2013 - April 2016 | |
| Rev. Jaisen A. Thomas | May 2016 - April 2019 | |
| Rev. Saju C. Pappachen | May 2019 - Present | |